How to Choose a Dog Coat: A Practical Guide for Every Dog

By Rebecca Gadd, Founder of Goldpaw Series


I've been making dog coats for twenty years. And the question I get more than any other is still: does my dog really need a coat?

Wrong question. The right one is: what does this dog need, in these conditions? Because the answer is almost never the same twice, not across breeds, not across seasons, and honestly not even across dogs in the same household. (More on that at the end.)

Here's what I've learned from two decades of thinking about this.



Start With the Dog, Not the Coat

Before you look at a single product, think about your dog's situation:

Thermal mass matters. Small dogs lose body heat fast. A five-pound Chihuahua and a ninety-pound Labrador experience the same 40-degree morning very differently. The smaller the dog, the more a coat does for them.

Coat type matters, but it's not as simple as thick coat = warm dog. Thin single-coated breeds like Greyhounds, Vizslas and Whippets, have almost no natural insulation and feel wind chill and air temperature acutely. Double-coated breeds like Huskies and Bernese Mountain Dogs handle cold and wind remarkably well when dry, that dense undercoat is essentially a built-in windbreaker. Wet plus wind is a different story. A thoroughly soaked double coat loses much of its insulating value, and wind accelerates heat loss fast. That's the combination where even a fluffy dog benefits from a waterproof layer. Plus you can avoid hours of wet dog smell.

Age matters enormously. Senior dogs have a harder time regulating body temperature, often carry less muscle mass to generate heat, and frequently have arthritis that worsens in the cold. A coat isn't a luxury for an older dog but a supportive tool for  their health and comfort. It helps them maintain body weight by conserving the energy they'd otherwise burn just staying warm. It keeps joints warm and moving. In cold climates, depending on how warm you keep your house, a senior dog can benefit from wearing a Stretch Fleece all day long even indoors..

Activity level matters. An active dog on a vigorous hike generates body heat. The same dog standing around at an outdoor event, or sleeping on the couch in a drafty house might love a little warm up.

Acclimatization matters more than most people realize. Think about what your dog is used to, not just the number on the thermometer. A dog that grew up in Florida experiences 40 degrees very differently than a dog that grew up in Minnesota. And if you keep your house on the cool side, remember that 65 degrees can feel uncomfortable to an older, less active dog in ways it wouldn't to a young, energetic one. When in doubt, mentally bump the temperature down a few degrees for senior dogs, small dogs, and dogs with thin coats and dress them accordingly.




The Coat Types: What Each One Actually Does

Fleece — the everyday layer

A good stretch fleece is the workhorse of dog outerwear. It adds warmth without bulk, moves with the dog, and is comfortable enough for all-day wear including indoors for dogs that need it.

Senior dogs especially benefit from fleece worn throughout the day in cooler weather: it helps them maintain body temperature without expending energy, keeps joints warm and moving, and can genuinely ease arthritis discomfort. My older dogs all live in their Stretch Fleeces as soon as the weather turns. When we go for walks I layer a coat over the top but the fleece stays on all day.

Look for four-way stretch (so it moves with the dog rather than restricting movement), recycled fabric if sustainability matters to you, and a pullover design without straps and velcro if you want something comfortable enough for extended wear.

The Goldpaw Stretch Fleece comes in sizes 2 through 30. In 2016, Whole Dog Journal called it simply "the nicest dog coat we've ever seen for warmth, fit, and comfort." We're still hearing that.

Double fleece — serious warmth, no bulk

Two layers of stretch fleece bonded together gives you significantly more warmth than a single layer, while remaining far less bulky than a traditional insulated coat. For small dogs especially, this is a revelation: serious warmth without a maze of closures and straps, in sizes that actually go small enough. The Goldpaw Double Fleece goes down to a size 6, with custom sizing available down to a size 4.

Waterproof coats — for wet weather

Wet fur loses its insulating properties fast. So a waterproof coat isn't really about warmth — it's about staying dry enough that the warmth you have doesn't disappear the moment it starts drizzling.

My dog Edith would like me to mention that she disagrees with all outerwear on principle. She has, however, come to tolerate the Rainpaw, which I take as a ringing endorsement. Look for bonded stretch construction (so it moves with the dog rather than fighting them), a brushed finish that eliminates noise, (stiff raincoat crinkle bothers a lot of dogs) and coverage that actually reaches the belly and flanks. The Goldpaw Rainpaw has a shawl collar, extended hip coverage, and reflective trim for the short, grey days of a wet winter.

Full-body suits — for maximum coverage

For dogs who need legs, belly, and neck covered because of their beautiful flowing hair, skin conditions, surgery recovery, or just because they get genuinely, miserably cold, a full-body suit is in a different category than a standard coat. The Goldpaw Ski Suit is our warmest: fleece-lined, waterproof shell, stretchy sleeves. The Flight Suit is lighter and wind/water-resistant, great for year-round use and for keeping a thick-coated dog clean without overheating them and protected without squishing down their warm floof.

Sun protection — not just for summer

This one surprises people. UV-protective garments aren't seasonal, they're for any dog whose skin needs protection from the sun or environment year-round. Dogs with alopecia, autoimmune skin conditions like pemphigus, healing skin after surgery, or just sensitive skin. Our own black Lab Luke wore a Sun Tee every day after his pemphigus diagnosis, and it totally changed all of our quality of life. The Goldpaw Sun Shield Tee and Sun Suit offer UPF 50+ protection through the fabric construction itself (no chemical treatments) in a lightweight jersey that's comfortable in warm weather or indoors.




Getting the Fit Right

Measure girth, not just length. The most common sizing mistake is leading with body length. Girth ( the circumference of the chest at its widest point, just behind the front legs) is the measurement that is the perfect starting place.

Snug is right; too big is wrong. A well-fitting dog coat should move with the dog like a second skin, not compressive, but not sliding around or bunching up either. There's a tendency to think bigger means more comfortable. In reality, a coat that's too large will shift, ride up, and bunch in ways that restrict movement and reduce warmth just as much as one that's too small. The right fit stays put.

Layer strategically. One heavy coat sounds simpler than two lighter ones. In practice, a fleece under a waterproof shell is warmer, more versatile, and much easier to manage, you can add or remove one layer mid-walk depending on conditions. It's how we dress ourselves in cold weather, and dogs benefit from the same logic.




For Small Dogs

Small dogs need coats more than almost any other group as they just don't have the thermal mass to retain heat efficiently. A tiny dog in cold weather isn't being dramatic. They get cold faster, and colder, than a larger dog in the same conditions.

The trap with small dogs is thinking that more structure means more warmth. A coat with straps, multiple buckles, and fiddly closures sounds serious, but every gap at a closure point is a heat leak, and the whole thing is a wrestling match to get on and off. A simple pullover fleece fits close, moves with the dog, and tends to be warmer in practice. Make sure sizing actually goes small enough since a lot of brands' very smallest size will be too big for a tiny dog. The Goldpaw Stretch Fleece starts at a size 2, and the Double Fleece goes down to size 6 standard with custom sizing available, which covers dogs of just a few pounds with something that genuinely fits.




For Senior Dogs

Cold is harder on old bodies. Joints ache more. Energy reserves are lower. A coat that helps an arthritic dog move more freely on a winter walk is genuinely therapeutic, not just a nicety.

Consider indoor wear for senior dogs in cool climates or cool houses. A lightweight fleece worn during the day costs nothing in comfort and can make a meaningful difference in how a senior dog feels, moves, and even maintains weight. When you go outside, layer over the top.

Ease of getting it on matters more with senior dogs too. A simple pullover without straps, buckles, or complicated positioning is much less stressful for a dog with stiff joints and for the person trying to dress them. Our Stretch Fleece can be put on while the dog is laying down, lol. 




For Dogs That Hate Wearing Clothes

This comes up constantly, and I've heard hundreds of versions of the same story: "My dog hates clothes, but he loves his Goldpaw fleece." Ditto with Cats. 

Here's what I've come to believe: most dogs don't hate wearing clothes. They hate wearing uncomfortable clothes. Stiff fabric, restrictive fits, scratchy seams, noisy materials, straps that waggle around, all are legitimate complaints, and dogs are right to object.

A garment that moves with the dog, sits close without binding, and uses soft fabric tends to get forgotten about within minutes. The dog stops noticing it's there. Start with a lightweight fleece rather than a heavy structured coat. Put it on, give a treat, go for a walk. Don't make a production of it. Most reluctant dogs come around quickly when the garment genuinely doesn't bother them. Pretty soon, they might just find that being warm is pretty great.




The Hot Take Nobody Talks About: Listen to Your Dog

Here's the thing I wish more people considered: dogs have preferences. Just like people.

I have two English Setters with similar builds and similar coats. One is older and thinner, so you'd think she'd be the one who wants a coat. She couldn't care less about being warm. The other is younger, plumper, and so very lazy. He loves wearing coats. He likes being warm. Frankly I suspect he just likes feeling like he belongs to someone, because he loves a sun tee all summer too. 

Same breed. Same household. Completely different preferences.

Watch your dog's signals. Do they seek out warm spots, curl up tight, shiver on walks, or perk up noticeably when they have a coat on? Those are the dogs who want one. Are they wary of every garment and seem genuinely unbothered by cold? Maybe they don't need one.

A coat should serve the dog, not the owner's peace of mind. When it's the right coat for the right dog in the right conditions, they'll usually tell you. But remember, that just like people, dogs change over time. This winter is the first one that our old girl looked pleased to see her fleeces, and sure enough she’s wearing one on the couch right now. 




Shop Goldpaw's full coat collection at goldpawseries.com — including the Stretch Fleece, Double Fleece, Rainpaw, Ski Suit, Flight Suit, and Sun Shield collection.



Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


You may also like

View all
Example blog post
Example blog post
Example blog post